This issue featured the dna results that showed thomas jefferson had the same halotype as descendants of eston hemings. Madison hemings s use of the words concubine and treaty hardly suggests a romance. Resolving the sally hemings myth jefferson policy journal. Revisiting thomas jefferson and sally hemings descendants now that dar accepts dna testing in 1998, the journal nature reported that jefferson had a slave mistress sally hemings with whom he fathered six children, basing the claim on a pairing of historical records with dna evidence tracing ychromosomes. And according to madison hemings, jefferson began his sexual liaison with sally. Eston hemings jefferson was born to sally hemings, a mixedrace slave, on may 21, 1808 in monticello, virginia.
Eston hemings jefferson may 21, 1808 january 3, 1856 was born a slave at monticello, the youngest son of sally hemings, a mixedrace slave. A dna test of hemings descendants revealed genetic evidence indicating that jefferson fathered her children. The basic outline of madison hemingss account, including his mothers treaty with jefferson and the freedom granted to him and his siblings, was well known to his community before it was published. The jefferson miscegenation legend in british travel books. Dna evidence proves that thomas jefferson fathered at least one child by sally hemings confirming the results of research published by sam sloan years ago, dna evidence has just proven that thomas jefferson was the father of at least one of the five children of sally hemings. Additionally, the dna study found no link between the descendants of field jefferson and thomas woodson 17901879, whose family members have long held that he was the first son of thomas jefferson and sally hemings. Annette gordonreed and the jefferson dna myth history.
He has stated this in emails to me, in nature journal january 7, 1999, the new york times article of early 1999 and in other publications. Madison hemings the treaty legend thomas jefferson heritage. After the civil war, he moved to memphis, tennessee, where he achieved wealth as a cotton broker. Annette gordonreed and the jefferson dna myth history news. Madison even acknowledged that thomas jefferson didnt treat him and his siblings like. In the second half of the 20th century, the historian winthrop jordan added new fuel to the fire, arguing in a 1968 book that sally hemings became pregnant only when jefferson. The publication of dna test results showing that thomas jefferson was probably the father of one of his slave sally hemings s children has sparked a broad but.
Thomas jefferson and sally hemings ohio university. The monticello foundation commissioned its study, which in 2001 concluded jefferson was likely the father of eston hemings and the other children. Madison hemings provided an account of his mothers life that was published in. Gordonreed makes explicit at the beginning of thomas jefferson and sally hemings that she is not trying to prove that they had a sexual relationship. Monticello affirms thomas jefferson fathered children with. Madison hemings grew up on jeffersons monticello plantation. After the publication of the dna evidence, ellis, who wrote of himself as one of those students of jefferson who previously questioned the possibility of a relationship with hemings, made plain.
An american controversy is the definitive look at a centuriesold question that should fascinate general readers and historians alike. Special video reports the history of a secret jefferson. If jefferson had an affair with sally hemings, we have to. Report of the scholars commission carolina academic press. Other evidence supports thomas jeffersons paternity as well, including his presence at. Many people, including some jefferson scholars, refused to accept the. Madison hemings provided an account of his mothers life that was published in an ohio newspaper in 1873. James madison hemings was the son of the mixedrace slave sally hemings. Provides a history of the politically motivated allegation and presents evidence for an alternate paternity candidate. He was the third of her four childrenfathered by her master, president thomas jeffersonto survive to adulthood. Hemings was said to have a child born in 1790 after she returned from paris.
Shortly after it appeared, dna testing established a genetic link between a male jefferson and eston hemings, madisons. May 8, 1835 june 12, 1892, was an american businessman, and during the american civil war, a soldier in the union army who was promoted to the rank of colonel. The question is which more than two dozen adult jefferson men who were in virginia at the time he was conceived was estons father. Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was probably the father. Monticello association the descendants of jeffersons daughters martha and mary for the last couple of years has invited hemings descendants to family reunions.
Fawn brodies book on the subject received a good deal of criticism from. In spite of the paucity of evidence, those who believe in this long affair between jefferson and hemings argue that sufficient proof could be found in the memoirs of madison hemings. Over the last two centuries a debate has persisted concerning the level of intimacy thomas jefferson shared with sally hemings. Jeffersonian democracy, books, articles, and internet commentaries continue.
History, memory, and civic culture jeffersonian america taylor, jan ellen, onuf, peter s. An american controversy by annette gordonreed university of virginia press, 1997. The publication of dna test results showing that thomas jefferson was probably the father of one of his slave sally hemings s children has sparked a broad but often. The hemings refuse to dna test william hemings son of madison hemings because they are happy with the current results. The dna study in 1998 reported a y dna match between the jefferson male line and a male descendant of eston hemings. Madison hemings, another of sallys sons, said that he and his siblings were jeffersons children and his only slave children in a report which accords in much of its substance with other sources. Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was probably the father of all hemings children.
Discusses jeffersons health, the dna study, the jefferson hemings scholars commission report, paris, madison hemings and jeffersons overseer. According to this interview, thomas and sally initiated an affair while they were together in paris from 1787 to 1789. Oct 04, 2008 shortly after it appeared, dna testing established a genetic link between a male jefferson and eston hemings, madison s brother. The book was released a year before the dna test results that convinced even. Harriet hemings may, 1801,noted in farm book 175 in jeffersons hand was born into slavery at monticello, the home of thomas jefferson, third president of the united states, in the first year of his presidency.
Dixon attorney at law introduction thomas jefferson, the president of the united states and owner of the virginia plantation monticello, was accused in the federalist press in the early 1800s of fathering children by his slave sally hemings. Annette gordonreed, a professor of law at new york law school, doesnt take a position for or against the proposition that thomas jefferson may have had a liaison. At the age of 68, madison hemings claimed the connection in his memoir published in 1873, which attracted national and international attention. Both said that thomas jefferson fathered hemings children. Report of the scholars commission on the jefferson hemings matter 4 introduction 4 background to the controversy 4 the scholars commission 5 assessing the evidence 7 the almost total absence of information about sally hemings 7 assessing the arguments 7 the dna tests 7 madison hemings 1873 statement 8. And the evidence available, now that it has been examined fairly and in detail by annette gordonreed, makes clear that she was very likely the loved mistress of thomas jefferson. Dna evidence in 1998 supported the widely accepted conclusion that he was the son of thomas jefferson, the third president of the united states and the principal author of the declaration of independence.
Madison hemings was born in 1805, the third of the four children of sally hemings who reached adulthood. But gordonreed is determined to prove that theirs was a consensual relationship based on love. The basic outline of madison hemings s account, including his mothers treaty with jefferson and the freedom granted to him and his siblings, was well known to his community before it was published. In the majority view, the dna evidence is consistent with jefferson being the father of eston hemings, plus the historical evidence favors jeffersons paternity for all of hemings children.
Jefferson owned a hotel in madison, wisconsin, in the 1850s. Apr 20, 2010 the hemings case against jefferson rests, essentially, on three skeletal pieces of evidence, framed by a selective exclusion of all the exculpatory evidence pointing to jeffersons innocence. The hemings case against jefferson rests, essentially, on three skeletal pieces of evidence, framed by a selective exclusion of all the exculpatory evidence pointing to jeffersons innocence. Oct 05, 2008 madison hemings s use of the words concubine and treaty hardly suggests a romance. Born into slavery by his mothers status, he was freed by the will of jefferson in 1826. Largely as a result of revived interest in this case following gordonreeds book, a ydna analysis of carr, jefferson and hemings.
Gordonreed has now turned her attention to an even more ambitious. Was edmond bacon defending an icon or was madison hemings wrong when he said jefferson didnt like farming. A decade later, dna testing had evolved to include more information about. In 1997, annette gordonreed published a book that analyzed the historiography and noted how historians since the 19th century had accepted accounts by jefferson descendants while rejecting accounts by madison hemings, a son of sally hemings, and israel jefferson, another former slave at monticello. Dna tests show that a descendant of eston hemings carries a jefferson gene. Madison hemings, who learned carpentry at monticello, told the pike. There was no match between the dna of woodson, hemings and carr descendants.
Evidence from a 1998 dna test showed that a descendant of eston matched the jefferson male line, and historical evidence. The dna testing found no genetic link between the hemings and carr descendants. A new book raises serious doubts about the allegation that thomas jefferson had a sexual relationship with the enslaved sally hemings that produced one or more children. What was the age difference between thomas jefferson and sally hemings. The recent publication of the results of dna tests implies that eston hemings, sallys. Mar 24, 2016 the dna study in 1998 reported a y dna match between the jefferson male line and a male descendant of eston hemings. Madison hemings, another of sallys sons, said that he and his siblings were.
There was no match between the dna of descendants of jefferson and woodson. It meant that thomas jefferson or any other jefferson did not father thomas woodson as stated in callenders 1802 article. Moreover, there is new dna available from madison s son william, but the. Foster hoped that this dna study, either alone or combined with historical evidence, would resolve the jefferson hemings issue. Shortly after it appeared, dna testing established a genetic link between a male jefferson and eston hemings, madisons brother. Since this was written in 1997, dna testing has confirmed that sally hemings was not the mistress of any of the men in the carr family. Elizabeth hemings and her children lived at john wayles plantation during his lifetime. Based on historical and dna evidence, historians widely agree that jefferson was likely the father of all hemings children. By madison hemings s and other accounts, sally hemings and some of her siblings were the children of john wayles, thomas jeffersons fatherinlaw, making her the halfsister of jeffersons wife, martha wayles jefferson 17481782.
Jeffersons monticello finally gives sally hemings her. This updated edition of the book also includes an afterword in which the author comments on the dna study that provided further evidence of a jefferson and hemings liaison. Fosters statement that the dna evidence neither definitely excludes nor solely implicates jefferson in the paternity of sally hemings children. The dna study did prove paternity of a jefferson family member and. Andrew holowchak is the author of many books about thomas.
Buy a cheap copy of thomas jefferson and sally hemings. The jefferson enigma jefferson post dna jeffersons blood. Dna evidence proves that thomas jefferson fathered at least. Feb 19, 2017 four of hemings s children lived to adulthood, and documentary evidence, along with genetic links found in dna tests of hemings and jefferson descendants in 1998, led most historians to believe. The dna testing found no genetic link between the hemings and carr descendants, refuting jeffersons grandchildrens assertion that his carr nephews fathered sally hemings s children. In gordonreeds new book, the hemingses of monticello, her single most revealing source is the memoir of madison hemings, printed by a newspaperman named s. Background dna study thomas jefferson sally hemings. Apr 15, 2012 what was the age difference between thomas jefferson and sally hemings.
Has dna testing proved that thomasjefferson fathered at. The announcement in 1998 that dna testing proved some link between the. A trial analysis of the evidence on paternity richard e. James madison hemings january 18, 1805 november 28, 1877 was the son of the.
The descendants of sally hemings youngest son, eston, however, are clearly related to the jeffersons. The book caused a sensation in the sedate world of jefferson scholarship. Madison hemings memoirbut holowchak suggests that hemings peddled a. Two of her childrenmadison and estonindicated that jefferson was their father, and. Kearses most recent visit to madisons plantation promised to be even more. Four of hemings s children lived to adulthood, and documentary evidence, along with genetic links found in dna tests of hemings and jefferson descendants in 1998, led most historians to believe. Thomas jefferson and sally hemings goodreads share book.
I would like to see a book as well of the three books ive read specifically about the jefferson hemings story, this is the best written. The most compelling element of all, however, is her extensive and careful research, which often allows the evidence to speak for itself. What was the age difference between thomas jefferson and. It is widely believed that jefferson and hemings had a 38year secret relationship beginning in paris several years after the early death of his wife. Her mother said they descended from a president and a slave. Fosters statement that the dna evidence neither definitely excludes nor solely impliocates jefferson in the paternity of sally hemings children. Her brother madison hemings later said she had gone to washington, dc to join their. The dna evidence is reasonably compelling on its own, establishing a perfect. Harriet is believed to be the daughter of sally hemings and the widower thomas jefferson. Most historians who have considered the question believe that his father was thomas jefferson, the united states president.
The above quote from lander and ellis does not just eliminate tom woodson from jeffersons bloodline, but, by assuming that tom woodson was a son of sally hemings, calls into greater question the paternity of beverly, harriet, and madison hemings for whom currently no dna evidence exists that might verify or eliminate them from jeffersons. Report of the scholars commission, it presents the conclusions of a yearlong inquiry by more than a dozen senior scholars from. Nature, however, after exonerating jefferson in the birth of thomas woodson, claimed that the dna evidence proved that eston hemings the youngest of sallys childrenwas fathered by thomas jefferson. Many people, including some jefferson scholars, refused to. Dna testing of members of the jefferson and hemings families in. His admirers will be predisposed to interpret the liaison with sally hemings as a love affair, with jefferson and hemings cast in the role of americas most preeminent biracial couple, or they will question the reliability of the dna evidence, insisting that it is not scientifically conclusive or that it flies in the face of jeffersons. Because of the dna evidence, world book encyclopedia mentioned hemings for the first time in its 1999 edition, spokesman mike weinstein said. Monticello affirms thomas jefferson fathered children with sally. To wit, was she a just another houseslave or, as madison hemings put it, jeffersons concubine.
1393 292 466 1193 460 225 371 1168 63 3 83 1258 72 277 138 1369 236 1174 1353 1291 653 741 1013 1378 1159 557 882 598 946 1406 1391 396 188 1136 1295 1266 1236 138 1412